Ignorance is Dasieobsneun Gippeum

An American guy I once met in Nepal two years in a row was incredulous when I turned down his offer of pot. “You come to Nepal and you don’t smoke?”

Smoking wasn’t the main reason he came–he was attached to the Kathmandu tattoo convention–but it certainly played a big part of his experience.  My not taking him up on his offer seemed in his mind to be like going to Rome and not eating pasta, to france and missing the Eiffel tower, like going to London and not getting rained on.

Tattoo Convention 2014

Tattoo Convention 2014

Interestingly, the guy had never set near the Himalaya, or any other mountains in Nepal for that matter, which put him in the minority of tourists there. I don’t think it had ever occurred to him that hiking in the mountains was even an option. He didn’t know the pleasure of striding into a new village, the thrill of seeing children and goats playing together, the brash music of Tibetan monastery over 3000 meters into the alpine wilderness.

Nor should he. I’m not picking on the guy. One of the pleasant parts of travel–of life, really–is that we can pick and choose our experiences. As our friend Cat Stevens says, “There’s a million ways to be.” But this attitude is rife amongst travelers.

In Korea, this mindset takes on a very specific form. This comic below sums up the attitude perfectly.

Easiest writing system in the world and the people who refuse to learn it.

Easiest writing system in the world and the people who refuse to learn it.

Never mind that it falsely conflates the unhappy foreigner with a non-Korean speaker (many of the unhappiest [or at least most vocal] expats here are quite proudly fluent in Korean).  The judgement here is clear: if you don’t speak Korean, you don’t deserve to complain/are lazy/and deservedly negative. This is a widespread belief the permeates much of the foreigner culture here. To be fair, there are absolutely some people like that. The comic isn’t entirely wrong. But it misses an important concept.

Even more so than Nepal, I think Korea has a real variety of options. Things like jimjilbang (spa), galbi (meat restaurant), and shopping are the favorite things for many foreigners here. Maybe most. In 3+ years here, I haven’t done any of those (apart from grocery shopping, of course.) Likewise, the long urban strolls I take most weekends are not on many other people’s list of favorite activities.

As you have no doubt guessed, I am including learning Korean as an interest. There is undoubtedly a bit of cultural Imperialism to this categorization–you don’t have to learn other languages when you speak English. Some people love learning new languages.  Other people don’t easily pick up new alphabets, or don’t care to. There are reasons not to as well. By not speaking Korean, you can exist in a sort of simplified Zen state where life is simple and uncomplicated. A good friend of mine calls this “the bubble.”

There are many advantages to learning Korean, of course. Reading signs, catching buses, chatting with co-workers are all worthwhile rewards. Participating in the culture you live in can be important. It can help communicate with students and is useful in a million other ways too. Learning Korean is a great thing to do.

Korean and English

There are also benefits, not least financial and liver-related, to not spending lots of money at the bar each weekend. Or to hiking a couple times a month. Or to walking instead of catching cabs, not eating meat, going to the gym. Many things that most of us don’t consistently do.

The idea that people who don’t speak Korean are lazy or not making an effort is  an unexamined position. There are good reasons to learn Korean, and if one was planning to live here for a long time it would make a lot of sense. But there are good reasons to do lots of things most people don’t do. And there are good reasons not to learn Korean as well. Just as it’s okay to go to Nepal for a tattoo convention and not go hiking.

These are my thoughts. I would like to hear yours.

Advertisements

2 responses to “Ignorance is Dasieobsneun Gippeum

  1. Hi Ahimsa. Arrived here via Gord on Facebook. I found this particularly interesting:

    “The judgement here is clear: if you don’t speak Korean, you don’t deserve to complain/are lazy/and deservedly negative.”

    I’ve noticed that foreigners in Korean expat circles are often concerned about their ‘right’ to complain, more so than about the validity/accuracy of those complaints or their source, which, according to this comic, appears to be (willful) ignorance and quasi-racist condescension. That might be more the point than the concept of ‘deserve.’ I’m kind of curious why people are so fixated on that.

    A quick look at any ‘argument’ in expat forums reveals that when those who complain about Korea are engaged, the complainants feel the *right* to complain is under attack more than the complaint itself.

    Here is a typical interaction:

    A: Korea is the most racist country in the world!
    B: You might want to consider how your own country treats ethnic minorities.
    A: Just because my country has racism, I can’t complain about Korea’s?
    B: No, I meant your opinion is silly.
    A: You’re a Korea apologist. Stop defending their racism.

    Something like that.

    I suspect it’s a weird reaction to the yoke of white guilt or something.

    • Interesting thoughts. To be honest, I go out of my way to avoid expat forums just because of the toxicity you describe. But there is a lot to think about there, about the tendency of foreigners to complain and overlook the faults of their own country. Maybe I will be able to write a future post about that. Thanks for the insightful comment!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s